HNNewShowAskJobs
Built with Tanstack Start
I captured my friend transiting the sun during a skydive(twitter.com)
37 points by bpierre a day ago | 12 comments
  • tetris11a day ago

    https://nitter.net/AJamesMcCarthy/status/1989027887689998561...

    • Atherosa day ago |parent

      So.. it's a composite and .. "transiting" isn't quite accurate either. hmmm :-(

      • snypher20 hours ago |parent

        >The sun in the background was sharpened via a stacked image but the image is 100% real and authentically captured in camera (see the video in the OP reply for real time view). Not a composite!

        He just kept shooting the sun after the jumper cleared, and stacked up those shots. I think saying it's a 'composite' devalues the image and just makes it seem like he cut out the jumper and pasted on to the sun.

        • Atheros7 hours ago |parent

          It does devalue the image indeed. He didn't cut out the jumper and paste it onto the sun but he did take images of the sun and paste them onto the jumper, using the jumper as a mask. Which seems to me like a distinction without a difference.

          If his images were real they would have shown the powered paraglider too. The images are a composite of photos that he took of the sun and a frame from the video that he took of the jumper.

          Is it pretty? Certainly! It's art! But it's 'photography' the same way the 'So Yummy' YouTube channel is cooking.[1]

          [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6abePkXncCM

          • 5 hours ago |parent
            [deleted]
      • JohnnyLarue17 hours ago |parent

        This is like saying long exposures don't count because they're composite images

        • Atheros7 hours ago |parent

          That doesn't make any sense. Did you mean double exposures?

          • tetris117 hours ago |parent

            Isn't a long exposure one where you leave the aperture open for a long time, but it still constitutes as a single take?

            • Atherosan hour ago |parent

              Yes

              Even multiple exposures of one frame of film is, as far as I can tell, still generally considered one photograph.

  • tanseydavid19 hours ago

    Love it. The concept and the execution. Just bought one for my new place.

  • kridsdale1a day ago

    What an achievement.

  • 4ndrewla day ago

    Incredible.