HNNewShowAskJobs
Built with Tanstack Start
3I/ATLAS shows perihelion burst and radial-only non-gravitational acceleration(old.reddit.com)
46 points by hnthrowaway0315 a day ago | 14 comments
  • boothbya day ago

    Breathless speculation aside, I think it would be extremely cool if we could identify, intercept and sample an extrasolar object at some point in my lifetime.

    • ProllyInfamous21 hours ago |parent

      The most amazing thing to me (after reading Wikipedia on this very-recent classification of "Interstellar Object"), is that only two prior have been confirmed, and all in the last decade.

    • m4rtinka day ago |parent

      By this point it looks like they are not that rare. Lets just hope the next one does not have enough delta-v to change its trajectory to intercept us - at a couple dozen km/s. ;-)

    • CamperBob2a day ago |parent

      Meanwhile, in this life, some dogs and cats were apparently being eaten, so we get this: https://www.space.com/space-exploration/nasa-is-sinking-its-...

      • Muromeca day ago |parent

        That just means that the first people making contact with the object will not be speaking English, not that it will not happen at all

  • yodona day ago

    > For the layman: These plots show a sudden burst of acceleration on the object, and the push points mostly in one steady direction within the orbital plane. A normal comet warms up and ramps its outgassing gradually, and breaking apart would look chaotic with the direction of thrust changing randomly.

    > Here we see one short, powerful jet, like a sealed pocket finally venting, so the speed jumps sharply while the path stays in the same plane; it accelerates but it surprisingly doesn’t change direction.

    > It resembles what a single thruster would do (what an incredible prospect!), but it can technically still be explained by a natural rupture of volatile ices in an ancient space rock.

    • tummlera day ago |parent

      Seems odd to me that there would be one short, powerful jet of a natural explanation. Why hasn’t this thing been outgassing like crazy the whole time?

      • HPsquareda day ago |parent

        Maybe it was cooking away like a sealed food container in a microwave, internal pressure building, then the seal is breached and the internal pressure is released in a single event.

      • aaroninsfa day ago |parent

        Current speculation is that it's a novel object type, unlike the conglomerate iceballs we call "comets," with a different origin and history.

        Unfortunately we did not make the heroic effort it would have taken to get a close look, so as with 1I/ʻOUMUAMUA we'll be left with enigmas and uncertainty.

        Unless of course it brakes hard into a parking orbit. :)

        • bigbuppoa day ago |parent

          I guess the aliens are here to watch the AI bubble pop.

          • aaroninsfa day ago |parent

            Plot twist: the aliens are AI and are here to watch the meat bubble pop!

  • ojosilva17 hours ago

    For the fans of the genre, some more speculation by the master speculator himself:

    https://avi-loeb.medium.com/post-perihelion-data-on-3i-atlas...

  • HPsquareda day ago

    Solar heating and outgassing on the side facing the sun.

  • a day ago
    [deleted]