HNNewShowAskJobs
Built with Tanstack Start
What's Hiding Inside Haribo's Power Bank and Headphones?(lumafield.com)
89 points by rozenmd 3 days ago | 28 comments
  • VBprogrammer4 hours ago

    I stick to Anker for cables, batteries and chargers. I'm sure they've had their own issues but everything I've bought feels well made. The only one I've had an issue with was a USB-C to everything else adaptor which weirdly stopped working after a week or two. I was surprised to find that their support was based in the UK (Cardiff if memory serves) and very efficiently processed a return and replacement.

    I've watched Big Clive's videos for too long to trust no-name Chinese things with anything involving mains potential or energy storage.

    • vardump37 minutes ago |parent

      IKEA 45W and 65W Sjoss chargers and braided cables are also good. Pretty cheap too.

      Those chargers have nice specs too. They support PD PPS (programmable power supply).

    • LunicLynx3 hours ago |parent

      I bought myself an anker powerbank because of all the rave around them. Mine behaves incredibly strange. Charged in seconds, then not containing half a phone charge. For a 20.000 mAh this was really disappointing. Probably a one of but still leaves the impression that this was looked at because it ruined the price for others.

      • literalAardvark2 hours ago |parent

        That's obviously a dud cell. Contact support if it's not several years old.

        • Melonaian hour ago |parent

          Had a tangential issue with an Anker power bank (screen was sometimes showing bogus charge essentially), and can confirm Anker E-Mail support is pretty good in my experience, they sent me a second unit (even though the first is still functional and I still use it just fine to this day), free of charge after a brief exchange.

          Might be worth a shot.

          • LunicLynxan hour ago |parent

            Okay thanks, I’ll try!

      • ycombinete19 minutes ago |parent

        They recently did a massive recall on a line of power banks for being fire hazards. Make sure it’s not one of them.

    • testdelacc139 minutes ago |parent

      Yeah same. I’ve bought Anker power adapters, cables, power banks, headphones. All of them have done incredibly well. They’re not immune to issues, because sometimes their suppliers let them down. But if that happens they’ll replace your product for free.

  • raphman33 minutes ago

    FWIW, the Haribo charger seems to be rather well made: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xT_t5nvFcoY (26:50, by ZeroBrain, a German YouTuber that disassembles electronic devices)

  • krackers5 hours ago

    The more interesting thing is that they were actually pulled. Did the manufacturer send a recall notice? (And if so why didn't they send a statement). I can't imagine Amazon themselves taking any action since they allow other junk to stay up

  • giantg22 hours ago

    Batteries that undercut the market price have serious flaws... who would have thought!

  • curiousObject3 days ago

    Why these batteries got all the attention - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45322135

  • arp24214 minutes ago

    How or why does a candy company decide to electronics? That's the mystery I need an answer to. What's next, Durex pizzas?

  • baiwlan hour ago

    This reminds me of when pvs-studio would post every single analysis they would make of popular C++ projects. It was a fun novelty back in the day. Just like these scans, which now are boring and overplayed.

  • frumiousirc4 hours ago

    I'm curious how the cost of performing these CT scans compared to the profit reaped by Haribo while the batteries were selling.

  • Y4444 hours ago

    I love the summary at the top. Cool thing to have.

  • mberger5 hours ago

    Gummy bears?

    • tclancy3 hours ago |parent

      My indulgent aunt once let me get a five pound bag of them from one of those Scoop Your Own candy stations. I left them in the rear window of her VW Rabbit for the better part of a summer day and they melted into a horrible blob that scarred me for life. Not sure why this Gummi Bear post is giving me flashbacks to that.

      But yes, those folks. Check the product shot in the article for their logo.

  • metalman3 hours ago

    not sure what is more interesting, the detailed information on lithium battery construction, or how they got a CT(cat) scanner, or the idea of having an industrial cat scanner around. those batteries were bizarely cheap and there was prior suggestion that these(others) were actualy fake with empty space or filler, which isn't the case, and all in all they just need to up the precision of there automated processes. nice piece of journalism.

    • notpushkin3 hours ago |parent

      > how they got a CT(cat) scanner

      Lumafield is a CT company: https://www.lumafield.com/

      • Cariocaan hour ago |parent

        Yup! And their whole social media “thing” is doing these kinds of on-topic analysis of (mostly consumer) devices

    • ChrisMarshallNY3 hours ago |parent

      > how they got a CT(cat) scanner

      I think they are becoming a lot more prevalent in labs, these days. They aren't the monster devices that many of us may be (unfortunately) familiar with.

      • butvacuuman hour ago |parent

        They can be a lot smaller when neither dose nor movement is a factor in imaging.

  • charcircuit4 hours ago

    Has anyone reported issues with this battery, from what I've seen online everyone has been happy with its performance. Maybe the uneveness called out by the article is not enough to matter. Not following the industry standard is not necessarily the tipping point of everything going wrong.

    • arcfour3 hours ago |parent

      "Well the batteries haven't caught on fire yet. I'm sure they're fine, despite the serious manufacturing defects that increase the risk of a fire substantially."

      You realize they stopped selling them, right? They don't do this for "nothing to worry about."

      • charcircuit3 hours ago |parent

        >increase the risk of a fire substantially

        The article doesn't state by how much it increased.

        >You realize they stopped selling them, right?

        I don't think Amazon is an authority on battery safety and are airing on the side of safety than making an actual judgements on the safety of it.

        • tclancy3 hours ago |parent

          No they are definitely not. You’re completely correct! They are, instead, an authority on what might get their asses sued to the moon and back and apparently found the cost/ benefit of selling this popular product to be negative. Any ideas what might cause that?

        • jacquesman hour ago |parent

          That lower than .5 mm margin on those edges may not have caused fires - yet - but if nothing is done about it then one day they will. That's an accident waiting to happen.