HNNewShowAskJobs
Built with Tanstack Start
Anna's Archive is sued for $13T(nme.com)
21 points by antonmks 10 hours ago | 9 comments
  • Terr_10 hours ago

    Saving people a few clicks, lawsuit PDF here.

    https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/files/2026/01/Annas-A...

    IANAL but I'm assuming their use of the word "theft" is purely for rhetorical effect--perhaps with an eye towards their demanded jury-trial--since most "theft" definitions require an intent to deprive, meaning it wouldn't apply to someone creating their own replica.

        COMPLAINT FOR:
        (1) Direct Copyright Infringement
        (2) Breach of Contract
        (3) Violation of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 U.S.C. § 1030
        (4) Violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. § 1201
        JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
  • araes9 hours ago

    So, they're suing Anna' Archive for $13T...

      - The combined market cap of NVidia ($4.35T), Apple ($3.88T), and Google (Goog, $1.9T+Googl, $3.62T) shares combined.
      - An amount larger than Every world stock market on Earth, except the NYSE and NASDAQ (the next closest is Shanghai at $9T)
      - ~5 months worth of all trades (market volume) on the NYSE ($2.685T/month)
      - ~1/10th of ALL world stock markets market capitalization.
      - ~1/2 the United States yearly Gross Domestic Product
      - 130x Spotify's own market capitalization (total stock value outstanding)
      - ~766x Spotify's own yearly revenue for 2024 ($16.96B)
    
    Just sue them for a gazillion quadrillion dollars or something. "Yes, judge. We estimate our damages at 1/10th of the entire world stock market, or approximately half the United States total economic output" Be difficult not to laugh at these people.
  • buckwheatmilk9 hours ago

    Fun fact: Daniel Ek just before founding Spotify was CEO of μTorrent. You will never guess what he used as initial music library for Spotify.

    Wheel of life I guess.

  • mmh00005 hours ago

    I briefly looked over the PDF, but I'm not a lawyer. If I understand correctly, they're suing "DOES 1 through 10".

    So, I'm assuming they're hoping for a "default judgment" against Anna's Archive, and then they'll presumably start taking domain names and any other hosting resources?

    Then, I assume in the end, nothing will really change, just like The Pirate Bay still exists in the open on a series of rotating domains.

    But at least the lawyers will be able to justify their job.

  • tokyobreakfast10 hours ago

    To put that in perspective, $13T is 130x the amount Dr. Evil held the world ransom for in Austin Powers.

    • burnt-resistor8 hours ago |parent

      130 evil pinkies

  • iamrobertismo10 hours ago

    I am personally not a very big fan of Spotify for a variety of reasons, I would not be against them losing this lawsuit. Especially with their moves toward AI, they seem to have very little respect for this media they claim to be defending.

  • Rendello9 hours ago

    For a less-serious but similar situation, Jason Scott (textfiles.com, Internet Archive) gave a hilarious DEFCON talk called "That Awesome Time I Was Sued For Two Billion Dollars":

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KSWqx8goqSY

  • antonmks10 hours ago

    Spotify and the three main major record labels sue Anna’s Archive for $13trillion for “brazen theft of millions of files containing nearly all of the world’s commercial sound recordings”.